Our Reviews

Randy is a true professional! The trip was quick and he had us into gators quickly. He’s got the best equipment and he will give you the best chance to have a successful hunt. 100% recommend booking a trip with him. If you book with anyone else you’re gambling with your money.

-Bryan R

He is still grinning ear to ear. Randy. You never disappoint.

-Jim Y

A little bruised and sore but we can't thank you enough for the amazing day. Your guidance, patience, and resilience of finding the right gators was amazing!! It was truly epic and we'll be talking about it for decades to come!! 🐊🐊

-Jill B

I had the opportunity to go frog gigging and bow fishing tilapia on a Muddy Tail Charter. It was a blast. I would highly recommend Muddy Tail Charters. I plan on booking more trips in the future.

-Paul P

Had a great time filling my gator tags with Randy. Not only is he an expert at gator hunting, he’s just a cool person to teach you the ropes. Thank you again. Would absolutely recommend and will be sharing with friends.

-Megan D.

Went out striper fishing with Captain Randy and had a blast. My kids (11 & 14) caught their limit within a couple hours. Definitely booking future trips here soon!

- Ashley B.

We had such a great time! Randy was very helpful and taught us a lot of new things. Very welcoming and professional. Definitely would recommend! Cant wait to plan our next day! Contact him for more information.

-Tiffany S.

Awesome captain he’s very personable and makes you feel like a long time friend . Highly recommended.

-Clay R.

We decided to book a family trip with muddy tail charters to try out bow fishing, we have never been and had no idea what to expect. I was very impressed with the assortment and quality of bows to pick from, there was smaller bows for my son and even a left-handed bow for my wife. Capt. Randy made sure that everyone felt good with the equipment before we headed out and took his time to teach us how it all worked. We had an amazing day and brought home enough fish to fill the freezer. We are all hooked on bow fishing now and are all talking about booking another trip.

- Charles and Mary K.

Randy is a great captain and person. Had an awesome time bow fishing with my kid and father. I would definitely recommend using him!

-Nick S.

Amazing experience! I booked a coastal fishing trip in December and it was unforgettable. Capt Randy was very helpful as it was my first time fishing ever. My brother in law and I had a blast and will definitely be back 😊

- Maria C.

Whether you're brand new to the gator world or a seasoned hunter, you have something to learn from Randy. I had a great time filling both my tags and learned a ton in the process. His set up is comfortable and he's highly professional. Would 10/10 recommend.

-Meg D.

Hands down one of the best trips I’ve ever been on. Would definitely recommend. Would definitely book again!!!

- Tony C.

I have been fishing with Randy several times, he knows were to go to get you the fish you want. Randy ’s very knowledgeable, professional, personable and dedicated to his skill. 10/10 would use Muddy Tail Charters.

-Chris J

Been fishing with capt matheny many times and have never had a dull trip. If anyone can put you on the fish it’s him! Highly recommend!!

-Mike B

Great charter! Randy really knows his stuff. Will be booking again soon!

-Anthony C.

Tried a redfish trip with Capt Randy and was impressed. We caught over 20 redfish, a bunch of snook, sheepshead and my son caught a giant black drum over 30 pounds! Capt Randy helped him to see it, cast to it and then fight it all the way to the boat. Great day with fish all day as well as a cool shore lunch on an island. We will be back.

- Bill M.

Capt Randy put us on two good gators in a matter of two hours. His boat is the perfect boat to gator hunt in and accommodate your guests comfortably. I would highly recommend him for new or seasoned gator hunters.

-Nick D.

Had a great time! I was down on vacation and decided to book a bass fishing trip. We were a little concerned that the weather wasn’t going to cooperate due to it being overcast and rainy however Captain Randy was still able to deliver and put us on fish. Almost right away the bobbers were going down and we were bringing fish in the boat. I even lucked out and caught a chain pickerel which was a first for me! We will definitely book another trip next time we are down!!

- Matt H.

Ya’ll wanna shoot fish go with this guy!! We shot till the cooler was overflowing with tilapia and cats!

- Steven B.

Got my first alligator with Capt. Randy! He helped me through the whole process from getting drawn for my tag to filling it. Absolutely amazing experience beginning to end and now we will be eating gator tail that I caught!

- Rachel D.

Randy is an awesome captain and person. I had an awesome time bow-fishing with my daughter and father. We couldn’t count how many tilapia we saw. I definitely will be fishing with Randy in the future.

-Nick S

Bass bass and more bass. Caught my PB at 9 pound, 3 ounce. I will be back next time I am in Florida.

- Mike T.

Capt. Randy took me on my first ever gator hunt and got me an 11’3” monster! Thanks again for the moment of a lifetime!!

- Zoe R.